Stardom
Leading roles for black actors in Hollywood were very scarce so when Dorothy heard that an all black production of Carmen Jones was being planned, she knew this was the role she had dreamed of. Carmen Jones was an Americanized version of the Bizet opera with new lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein. The lead character, Carmen, is a sultry vixen whose independent inclinations to love her men and then leave them lead to her violent demise.
The project was the mastermind of Austrian director Otto Preminger. Preminger was a director who liked to take risks and he was not afraid of controversy. The previous year, he had openly defied the Production Code by filming the controversial play The Moon Is Blue and he left the racy dialog intact. When the Production Board refused to give him a rating of approval, Preminger released the film without it. Preminger also could see that black actors were underused and not given the chance to show their full potential and he wanted to do something about it. Preminger also had a reputation of being a tyrant on the set and he was often brutal with his actors.
Dorothy arranged a meeting with Preminger to discuss Carmen Jones. He knew her from her work in Bright Road and when she came to his office, he was under the impression that she was interested in the part of Cindy Lou, the sweet demure girlfriend of Harry Belafonte at the start of the film. When Dorothy informed him that she was only interested in the role of Carmen, Preminger told her that she was not right for the part. Dorothy was furious but determined to change his mind. She bought a wig, a skirt and a low cut blouse that she wore off the shoulder. She met with Preminger again and he could not believe the transformation. He had found his Carmen.
Almost immediately, however, Dorothy had doubts about her own ability to play the part. This time it was Preminger's turn to convince her that she could do it. Dorothy cooked him his favorite dinner of cold steak and cucumbers and after dinner one thing lead to another. It would be the start of a long and troubled relationship.
The filming of Carmen Jones progressed smoothly. Both Dorothy and Belafonte were disappointed to learn that their voices would be dubbed for the singing sequences. Carmen Jones was released in November of 1954 and it was a resounding success. Dorothy was all over the media. She appeared on the cover of the November 1, 1954 issue of Life, photographed as Carmen by Philippe Halsman. The next few months would be a whirlwind round of premieres, promotions and photo shoots. It was heavily rumored that she would receive an Academy Award nomination. She refused to listen to the gossip but when the nominations were announced in February of 1955, she read her name along with Audrey Hepburn, Jane Wyman, Judy Garland and Grace Kelly. Dorothy Dandridge was the first black woman to be nominated in the category of Best Actress. The buzz in Hollywood for the next month was that the winner would be either Dorothy or Judy Garland. But when the winner was announced in late March, the surprize winner was Grace Kelly for her role in The Country Girl.
Dorothy next attended the Cannes Film Festival with Preminger and then returned to the U.S. for more nightclub work as she awaited her next film offer. She did not have to wait long. She was wanted for the role of Tuptim in The King and I. Dorothy did not like the part which she considered nothing more than a slave and was further disappointed to see that it was not the leading role. Preminger advised her not to do it. She turned down the role but her decision would haunt her for the rest of her life. She later felt that her refusal to play Tuptim was the beginning of her downfall in Hollywood. The role was given to Rita Moreno and the film was a huge success.
Dorothy's success and fame changed her life tremendously. She bought a beautiful home overlooking Los Angeles and she continued to get lots of publicity. Not all of it was good. In 1957, the infamous tabloid Hollywood Confidential ran a story about an alleged one night stand between Dorothy and a bartender in Lake Tahoe. Dorothy sued them. Fame also affected Dorothy's personal life. She had not heard from her sister Vivian in over two years and she did not know where Vivan was living. She spoke to her mother every day. Ruby Dandridge was a successful character actress and was now living with another woman. Geneva had been shown the door a few years previously and when she came to Dorothy for financial help, she was refused. Dorothy would never forget her beatings from Geneva.
It seemed that Dorothy now moved in mostly white circles. Her relationship with Preminger would increasingly become strained due to the fact that he was married and they could not be seen in public together. Dorothy found that white men were especially attracted to her and would go out with her but to most of them, marriage would be out of the question. Most all men, black or white, found Dorothy to be a fascinating woman. In addition to her beauty, she was very intelligent and a wonderful conversationist. She was particularly fascinated by psychology and was constantly reading books about the subject.
It would be almost two years following the making of Carmen Jones before Dorothy set foot in front of a movie camera again. Darryl Zanuck wanted her for the role of Margot Seaton in Island In The Sun. Based on the bestselling book, the story dealt with two interracial relationships and was of course highly controversial. The two relationships would involve Dorothy's character and John Justin and between Joan Fontaine and Harry Belafonte. The producers were afraid to go far with the relationships, however, and the film suffered as a result. Dorothy herself protested that her key scene with Justin displayed no intimacy whatsoever despite that it was a love scene. The film was successful upon release due to the controversial theme, but critics dismissed it as being simply boring.
Dorothy's next project was an Italian/French production called Tamango which was more daring (Dandridge and Curt Jurgens have some steamy scenes together, on screen and off) but the film was not released in the U.S. until four years later. Today, it is considered a cult classic.
In 1959, Samuel Goldwyn announced that he would film George Gershwin's musical Porgy and Bess. The story was highly unpopular with blacks and when Harry Belafonte and Dorothy were approached to star in the lead roles, Belafonte flatly turned it down. He urged Dorothy to do the same. Dorothy did not want to do it but all she could think about was The King and I and the role that she had turned down. She was in a turmoil because here was a big budget Hollywood production. Her past two films (Tamango and The Decks Ran Red) had been low budget foreign productions and it looked as if Hollywood work was slowly eluding her. She reluctantly accepted but the entire shoot was to be an unhappy one. Director Reuben Mamoulain was replaced with none other than Otto Preminger. Their relationship was now over and Preminger was particularly harsh with Dorothy during the filming. His reprimands were often so cruel and embarrassing that she would rush from the set in tears.
Sidney Poitier and Sammy Davis, Jr. were her co-stars in the film. Porgy and Bess was not as successful as Carmen Jones and the reviews were mediocre. Dorothy managed to rise above it all, however and won a Golden Globe Award for her performance.
Dorothy did not know it but her career would be downhill from here.