One Equals Two

The following is a proof that one equals two. Obviously there must be a flaw in it. When you think you've found it, select the line that results from the incorrect operation or assumption to see if you're right. If you don't have a browser that supports <SUP>, look at the proof on the right. Otherwise you can look at the one on the left.

For two numbers a and b, we want to prove:

 
     a = b                            a = b
    ab = b2           (line 2)       ab = b^2
 -(ab) = -(b2)        (line 3)    -(ab) = -(b^2)
 a2-ab = a2-b2        (line 4)   a^2-ab = a^2-b^2
a(a-b) = (a+b)(a-b)   (line 5)   a(a-b) = (a+b)(a-b)
     a = a+b          (line 6)        a = a+b
     a = 2a           (line 7)        a = 2a
     1 = 2                            1 = 2

Please note that I did not come up with this proof. It was passed on to me from someone who got it from one of his math professors.


Return to Lee's home page.
lkseitz@hiwaay.net
Created: 27 Jan 1996; Last Modified: 1 Jul 2008